The best of the Toronto & Montreal markets compared....
LocationLet's face it, as down-
towners,
St. Lawrence is rather convenient for us on all but the laziest or coldest of days. Door to door in less than 30 minutes.
Marche Jean Talon is not quite so handy. It is in Montreal where I
occasionally live. But even from my place in Montreal it's still a solid hour to get there and is not exactly downtown.
Public transit options about equal to both markets.
Edge St. Lawrence
Layout/SizeSt. Lawrence is probably physically bigger, but Jean-Talon felt a lot more spaced out and not so overwhelmingly busy. I liked the mix of indoor & outdoor at Jean-Talon vs the two buildings at St. Lawrence.
Edge: Jean Talon
Fish & SeafoodDefinite edge to St. Lawrence. Not a heck of a lot of seafood at Jean-Talon.
St Lawrence

St. Lawrence

Fresh fish on the way to St Lawrence

Edge: St. Lawrence
MeatSt. Lawrence - lots of regular steaks, ribs & poultry.
Jean-Talon - smoked meat and
charcuterie in general seemed superior.
Jean Talon

St Lawrence

St Lawrence

Edge: Equal
Quebecois Specialty FoodToronto really doesn't have a distinct food genre, instead we seem to have stolen good stuff from other cultures. The only moderately good thing in Toronto is the peameal bacon sandwich.
Jean Talon - good stuff like crepes, smoked meat, meat pies, sugar pies, maple syrup etc available.
Jean Talon


St Lawrence

Edge: Jean Talon
ProducePerhaps about the same variety & pricing, but Jean-Talon had lots of nice looking displays and vendors seemed to spend more time on presentation.
Jean Talon

Edge: Jean-Talon
FlowersAre there flowers at St. Lawrence? Only a meager amount as part of a produce store.
Jean Talon

St. Lawrence

Edge: Jean-Talon
Dry Goods
St Lawrence has a super cool store downstairs with lots of bulk & specialty dry goods downstairs. Add in a rice & bean store and it's an easy choice.


Edge: St Lawrence
Criminal ElementSt Lawrence has cops for helping people cross the street, Jean-Talon had cruisers driving through presumably looking for criminals.
Jean Talon

Edge: St Lawrence.
PastaWhole stores dedicated to the making of fresh pasta at Jean-Talon. At St. Lawrence, merely a small table.
Jean Talon

St Lawrence

Edge: Jean-Talon
Cheese
Surprisingly, St Lawrence appears to be superior with a couple huge cheese shops. Nothing too major at Jean Talon.
St. Lawrence

Edge: St. Lawrence
BakeryFuture Bakery vs sugar pies. Who can really make a call between these two.
St Lawrence

Edge: neutral
HousewaresOne extremely cramped store at St. Lawrence and a few other little guys. Jean-Talon has a few places, just as well equipped but a lot nicer & spaced out.
Jean Talon
St Lawrence

Beer
St. Lawrence has the LCBO down the street, Jean-Talon has specialty wine shops & local beer by the bottle.
Edge: Jean-Talon

Final Count - 2 up Jean Talon, but really they are about equal.